Just like other reviews, these are made very well. I listened to a review and didn't buy the pad for underneath, its fine. COMFORT is another thing....its like walking on extension cords. You will need slippers, for sure. Those sensitive to allergies might have a problem. I'm not sure if its coincidence or I might have caught a slight cold, so time will tell. (Its Flu Season right now) As far as the shedding hasn't happened with me yet, but because they are so heavy, I can see why people would be frustrated. I had to try them with the sale around Fifty Dollars each with Free Shipping, and glad I did. If you like the coastal look it will fit right in. Thanks Overstock! (Looks just like the pics provided online) UPDATE: Ok, so it's been a couple of months since buying the runners I AM looking for a pad to go underneath now. I haven't gotten the grit as others have stated (thankfully) but it is moving all over the place. When the puppy runs up the hallway he kicks it up and I'm constantly fixing it and its heavy so that's annoying. Also I am surprised to see some pulls in it. Wasn't that happy, but I like the beachy natural look so its not a total deal breaker. I think I'm going to buy 2 rugs for living and Dining room, but just a tad hesitant. Because it is so thick and junky, I'm thinking the chairs are going to get stuck in the fiber loops of the weave. How annoying will that be? I so like the looks and price better than others, but returning these rugs? Forget it people, they weigh a ton. Choose wisely.