Hamshire Reclaimed Wood 60-inch Bench by Kosas Home
We were worried about buying online, but the reviews on customer service were solid, so we went with it.
Pros: Solid bench, matches table perfectly, easy/fast to put together, Smooth finish with no seams/gaps in between "boards" of table top, NOT at all picnic table like, delivery was 5d to CA, and very well packed.
Cons: As others said, quality control issues - All the legs had some battle damage, 2/4 were pretty dented/scratched. BUT, went on Great Offer Stock chat, told them about it, and BAM, new legs mailed out. Done. Super easy!
Notes: Need two people flip/move after assembly between size/weight. Also, get a 13/16" deep socket wrench and ratchet, makes putting together super fast/easy.