After trying three different rugs, I finally found the perfect one for our living area. It feels nice for a sisal rug and, in my opinion, is softer than most sisal rugs. I have had no problems with shedding which is nice after having constant fuzz on the floor with my wool rug. The best part is how it really brightens up the room. I purchased the 9x12 and I'm considering ordering a smaller one for the entryway. I took away one star only because it's not completely flat in some areas (from being rolled up). It's been down about a month now, but maybe with more traffic in that area those places may eventually flatten all the way out. I still love it!