Start by saying I am one picky guy on dress shirts. Here is what I love about this shirt:
1) Collar looks great with tie - collar stitching is on the edge vs. back-set and the top edges of collar above knot touch/meet perfectly - crisp look
2) Despite a size 18 neck, the body of shirt has slimmer cut (I wear 46 jacket and 36 waist pant) fits great without looking 'too' fitted. Was worried that, like most larger neck sized shirts, it would look like a trash bag.
3) While the material is not that super tight broadcloth that starches super crisp, it's close enough. Has a tad bit of a satin look feel but don't let that sway you, it's more to do w quality of fabric. (I have not yet had cleaned starch yet so i may hold a nice press like a true broadcloth)
4) I have washed both of these shirts, twice, on gentle with woolite and they look great. I realize it say dry-clean only, but the money saved will pay for replacements should my washing experiment go sideways.
*Note - I also bought an Enzo blue pattern dress shirt and it too rocks. I think its the great looking collars that make it. I feel the collar is where most shirt manufactures fall short.