I had read these reviews prior to buying and gained some good insight on sizing, expectations and value. I was not disappointed at all - jacket is very sharp and quite heavy! Fits great and is snug around the wrists, keeping the cold out and keeping you nice and warm. I did ditch the removable collar after trying it on, have it handy for when the winter really arrives, but may not put it back on. For the price, this is a great value and exactly what I was looking for!