These are wonderful and fit true to size. They are very cute and exactly how they look in the photo. The black is very solid, which is sometimes a point of contention when some items are really charcoal grey when they claim black in the description. They seem to be a good quality item for a non leather material, well made and I would buy them again. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is because they are all one piece, i.e. the tongue area is attached and there is no opening the boot area to make them wider, but they fit me just fine although if someone has larger calves, they may have an issue getting them zipped all the way up because there is no way to get extra room by loosening the laces.