I purchased the Alba Festival Umbrella Holder Coat Tree for our office. I am very happy with the sturdy quality, and its modern look and design, but the umbrella holder does not look like the picture on the website or on the box. It should have been a round cylinder with a knob on the end. Instead, it looks like the umbrella holder I was shipped was the "S" shaped metal holder (with no knobs) that comes with the Festival Modern Large Capacity Coat Stand With Umbrella Holder. It's a good unit, just not exactly as I ordered. I can live with it, though, as I really like the design, its sturdiness and sturdy base and it matches our office decor very well. I would recommend it!