I'll start by saying that I ordered 2 of these to go on nightstands in our bedroom. I'll be sending them back today.
My 3-star rating is based on the fact that (a) parts of this lamp aren't of the quality that they should be, given the high price point (so I lowered the rating)... but... a few of the issues I faced (and which have led to my return of the lamps) were also caused by lack of good protection/packaging when these items were shipped to me, so I didn't give lower than 3-stars because I attribute those problems to human error (packaging) and not to the lamp, itself.
PROS --- This piece is beautiful. The glass base is gorgeous, and the shade is perfectly sized/proportioned to the base. The base and shade both seem to be high-quality and solid.
CONS --- I wasn't expecting the clear/flat base (below the aquamarine-colored recycled glass section) to be cheap acrylic; not a fan of that. Also, the clear blue finial at the top of the lampshade/harp is cheap acrylic, as well, and it literally broke off in my hand the second I tried to attach it to the lamp after placing the shade on top; again, not a fan. Additionally, these lamps arrived damaged. When the boxes were delivered to my house, they were badly crushed on the top half of each box. Inside, I found the lampshades bent/crushed, as well. I was able to "pop them back out" into their original shape -- and the wrinkles on the shade are only minimally visible to the eye -- UNTIL YOU TURN THE LAMP ON. Once the light is on, all of the wrinkled areas on the shade are a darker color... and it looks TERRIBLE. Complete deal-breaker. Both lamps arrived in this condition. So, so disappointing. (*NOTE* the bases were very well-protected, so there was no issue with those... but the shades were a mess, and the inner-packaging/protection inside the box was totally at fault, as it was basically non-existent).
Aside from the damage (and the 2 parts of the lamp that I felt were made of cheap material; mentioned above)... anyone thinking of buying these should know that they are HUGE. Absolutely huge. I bought them knowing the dimensions (and had actually marked it out on my nightstands to make sure they'd fit/work)... but wasn't prepared for how gigantic they truly are. They do fit, and if they weren't completely damaged I would be keeping them (again, GORGEOUS!). But be prepared. They are LARGE. Holy moly LOL. If you have a small space, these will certainly overpower it.