I've been looking for black oxfords for a while but it's hard to find any non-patent/shiny simple shoes to wear to work and with dresses. They are true to size (I ordered an 8.5) and they are comfortable to wear with socks. My only comment is that the lining of the shoe is brown which can be seen around the tongue/outer edges of the fabric by your feet which makes the shoe look a little cheaper than I'd like, I might stain it. But they wipe clean easily and the heel is the right height to be flattering. Overall happy with these on my first wear, hopefully won't have any issues later!