In fairness, I wanted to return these boots because of the quality of the boot. The black is ot a true black, but then again, I didn't amp up to the true leather price. The 9 Medium size is true to size. The height of the boot works, as it isn't too high, it reaches perfect, right below the knew. It's a comfortable boot and works with the skinny jeans or leggings. My problems, I have average calves, so the wide leg is too loose for me. I tried putting a wash cloth at the base of the boot and it sort of keeps the top of the boot stable. So...I'm ok with the boot. With my feet, I'm learning that I need to just purchase shoes from a store. If there were no shipping return fees, I'd have more fun shopping online and would take more risks.