I don't know if New Balance typically runs small or not, but these were too small for me. I ordered a 7.5, usually my go-to size for shoes. I have regular feet - not wide or narrow - and my toes were crunched. I think I would've been much happier with an 8. However, if it had fit me properly I think this would be a very comfortable, high quality shoe. I gave it a three because I am unsure of the durability, since I was unable to wear them.